Apple is being sued over the failed rollout of Apple Intelligence, and that's just the headline. The real story — pieced together from a bombshell report by The Information and years of internal chaos — is far worse. The WWDC 2024 demos may have been outright fabrications, and the dysfunction behind them stretches all the way back to when Siri was barely out of the box.
Siri Was Broken From Day One
Apple acquired Siri in 2010 for $200 million, and Steve Jobs personally shepherded it to the iPhone 4S in October 2011 — the same month Jobs died. What followed was a leadership mess. Richard Williamson, handed the reins under Scott Forstall, reportedly clashed with nearly everyone on the team and made a fateful call to update Siri only once a year, in lockstep with iOS releases. By the time Tim Cook fired both Forstall and Williamson after the Apple Maps disaster in 2012, the damage was done.
A Revolving Door of Leaders
Replacement hire Bill Stasior — Amazon's search guru — brought his own blind spots. His emphasis on search over AI vision created messy integrations and turf wars between old and new Siri teams. Google and Amazon had already lapped Apple in the smart assistant race by the time Cook made his boldest move yet: poaching Google's head of AI, John Giannandrea (JG), in 2018. JG reported directly to Cook — a clear signal Apple finally acknowledged it had a serious problem.
The AI Civil War Inside Apple
JG's AI/ML division and Craig Federighi's Software Engineering group were supposed to work together. They didn't. JG was universally liked but reportedly indecisive. His operational head, Robby Walker, obsessed over Siri's response speed while letting answer quality slide — a faster wrong answer is still wrong. Things deteriorated so badly that Federighi quietly built his own parallel AI team inside Software Engineering, hiring hundreds of ML engineers outside his official remit. JG's group earned a nickname from Federighi's side: "AIMLess." It stuck.
The WWDC 2024 Bombshell
This is where the lawsuit lands. The Information report alleges the Apple Intelligence features shown at WWDC 2024 — the rich personal context, the slick Siri integrations — weren't running on working devices at all. More damning: engineers on Siri's own team had reportedly never seen those features function. Apple's long-held internal rule is to only demo things that actually work internally. If these allegations hold, that rule was broken on stage in front of millions.
New Leadership, Cautious Hope
Apple has stripped Siri oversight from JG and Walker. The replacement is Mike Rockwell, who led the Vision Pro from concept to launch — a product with real polish, whatever you think of its price. Federighi remains involved and reportedly gave engineers the green light to use open-source models — a significant break from Apple's usual walled-garden approach.
Whether that's enough to undo a decade-plus of dysfunction is genuinely unclear. For the first time, Apple isn't just late to a category — it may be delivering the worst AI experience among its peers. That's new ground for a company whose whole identity is being last to ship but first in quality.
This article was created with AI help. If you want to watch the original video, please visit the link below.